Changing a roll
A rule whose trigger is When a Roll Is Made answers a roll before it settles: a reroll, a result turned round, a die added to the total. Like the other rules on Cards that answer the table, it never fires on its own. Whoever holds the card is asked as the roll is about to land. Everything here is in the trigger’s settings, in the Rules tab and on the effects canvas.
Which rolls it answers
Section titled “Which rolls it answers”Choose which rolls it Answers, Offered when the roll is about to (Succeed, Fail, or Either — whatever it shows) and Whose rolls. Then narrow it:
- Only a roll with Hope or Fear, When a die shows and its Faces (“when you roll a 1 on your Hope Die”), and Only rolls made with a trait.
- Only rolls made against — Only an attack against you, or Only an attack against you or an ally. Bone-Touched answers “an attack that succeeded against you”. A Reaction Roll, or a roll with no target, never fits.
- Only when the roller is beyond — I See It Coming’s “an attack made from beyond Melee range”. A creature on a square beside you, diagonals included, is in Melee range.
- Only when its target… and Only when the roller… test the creature attacked, or the one who rolled, as the roll lands. Ranger’s Focus rerolls “when you fail an attack against your Focus”: its target has Ranger’s Focus. Elusive Predator answers “when your Focus makes an attack against you”: its roller has it.
- Only a roll that used an Experience — Human’s Adaptability: “When you fail a roll that utilized one of your Experiences, you can mark a Stress to reroll.”
- Its range is to the creature the roll is made against — Danger Sense’s “an attack against you or an ally within Very Close range”. The card’s range is measured from you to the creature being attacked, and the attacker can stand anywhere.
- Only magic (a spell, or an attack dealing magic damage) — Anti-Mystica-Halitosis: “An attack, an ability, or a spell that deals magic damage or creates a magic effect fails automatically if used within Close range”. A roll with no magic in it never fits.
- Used without asking — the card is used the moment the roll fits it, with no prompt: Anti-Mystica-Halitosis’s “fails automatically”, Ill Omen’s “their Fear Die gains a bonus equal to the amount of Fear you have”, Chaos Magic Locus’s “they must roll two Fear Dice”.
- Only attacks made with — This weapon, The primary weapon, The secondary weapon, Any weapon, or an adversary’s The stat block’s standard attack. A rule on a weapon card that answers your own attack already answers only that weapon’s attacks, so the reroll a primary weapon gives isn’t offered when you attack with your secondary. Choose Every attack (no weapon needed) to switch that off. The Dragon Knight’s Comeback answers only its standard attack.
What it does
Section titled “What it does”In Daggerheart, What it does offers Reroll the Hope Die, Reroll the Fear Die, Reroll the Hope or the Fear Die, Reroll the Duality Dice, Make it a roll with Hope instead, Make a failure a success with Fear, Swap the Hope and Fear results, Add to the Hope or Fear Die, Reroll damage dice and One damage die at its maximum. Beside them are Roll dice and change the total, Make a failure a success — its dice stand, Make a success fail, and Make a reaction roll against it — on a success it fails (the Archmage’s Counterspell).
Three choices answer a d20 roll, which in Daggerheart only an adversary makes: Reroll the d20, keep the lower, Reroll the d20, keep the higher and Make them reroll the d20 — the new result stands. They never answer a player character’s Duality Dice — for those, pick one of the Hope, Fear or Duality Dice choices.
Rerolls with advantage
Section titled “Rerolls with advantage”Every reroll has The new roll is made: As it was rolled, With advantage or With disadvantage. Patron’s Boon, “When you fail a roll, you can spend 3 Hope to reroll with advantage”, is Reroll the Duality Dice made With advantage. Rebounding’s “reroll your attack with disadvantage” is the other way round.
A Hope or Fear Die reroll can also Keep the higher of the two: the new die stands only if it’s higher. Chaos Magic Locus’s “When a PC makes a Spellcast Roll, they must roll two Fear Dice and take the higher result” is Reroll the Fear Die, keeping the higher, used without asking.
The new roll adds one more source to the roll’s own, and they cancel as Daggerheart says: a reroll with advantage of a roll made at disadvantage is a plain roll. A player character’s Duality reroll rolls a fresh advantage die; an adversary’s d20 reroll rolls two d20s and keeps the higher (Comeback’s and Air Support’s “reroll the attack with advantage”).
Turning the result
Section titled “Turning the result”- Make a failure a success — its dice stand — True Strike’s “when you fail an attack, you can spend a Hope to make it a success instead”, and The House Always Wins. The Hope or Fear stays as rolled, so a success with Fear still gives the GM a Fear.
- Make a success fail — Bone-Touched’s “cause an attack that succeeded against you to fail instead”. Pair it with Only an attack against you: the attack misses before any damage is rolled.
Neither uses up your reaction.
Make them reroll the d20 — the new result stands is Danger Sense’s “force an adversary to reroll an attack”. Whatever the new roll shows, it stands.
Dice on the total
Section titled “Dice on the total”Roll dice and change the total rolls its Dice and adds them, or takes them off with Take it off the total. Four more settings:
- Paid any number of times — the holder chooses how many times to pay the rule’s price, and the change counts once for each payment, up to what they can pay. Umbral Veil’s “spend any number of tokens to give the result a -1 penalty per token spent” takes 1 off for each token; Fane of the Wilds adds +1 for each.
- How many of the dice — “roll a number of d6s equal to your Agility” (Vial of Darksmoke). Point it at the holder’s trait.
- Only the highest die counts — “add the highest result to your Evasion against the attack”. Taking it off the attack’s total is the same test.
- Rolled again until a result drops — Combo Strike: the die is rolled again and again until a result is lower than the one before, and every result counts. On a damage roll, that’s extra damage.
Damage dice
Section titled “Damage dice”Two choices answer a damage roll about to land, and nothing else:
- Reroll damage dice rerolls Each die showing a 1 or a 2, Any of them — the roller picks, or All of them. The new result stands.
- One damage die at its maximum is Versatile Fighter’s “mark a Stress to use the maximum result of one of your damage dice instead of rolling it”. It’s offered with the dice already down, like the other damage answers, and it raises the die that gains the most.
A damage roll can also take Roll dice and change the total, with Answers set to damage. The dice join that damage before it’s compared with the thresholds: Tusks’ “dealing an extra 1d6 damage”, Kick’s 2d6. For “When you succeed on an attack against a target within Melee range”:
- turn on Only damage from an attack that hit, so a burst or a spell with no attack roll doesn’t offer it;
- turn on Its range is to the creature the roll is made against, with a Melee targeting step.
Steps after its price run once the damage lands. Kick’s “and knocking back either yourself or the target” is a Targeting step set to The Creature It’s About, then the choice and the push. It’s offered with the damage dice already down, so the player sees the roll first. A damage roll from the sheet names no target, so a rule with that range isn’t offered on it.
Before the roll
Section titled “Before the roll”Before the roll: a bigger Hope or Fear Die is the one that happens first — “roll a d20 as your Hope Die”. Pick the Die and what it Becomes a. It is offered to the roller before they roll, never in the middle.
Costs, uses and range work as on any card. A consumable that answers a roll uses one up, and one with none left isn’t offered.