Reacting to someone else's card
Some cards are never played from your hand. They answer another creature’s play, and the table asks you when one could: a counter like Counterspell, or an interrupt like Silvery Barbs or Cutting Words.
Counter the spell?
Section titled “Counter the spell?”When an enemy in range casts a spell and you hold a counter, the prompt names the spell and its level.
- If you have more than one spell slot to choose from, pick the one to spend and press Submit Choice, or choose Don’t react.
- Otherwise press Confirm or Decline.
Depending on the card’s rule, the spell may still not fail:
- D&D 5e (2014 rules): a spell no higher than the slot you used fails. A higher one needs your spellcasting check against DC 10 + its level, and the caster’s slot is used either way.
- D&D 5.5e (2024 rules): the caster makes a Constitution saving throw against your spell save DC. A spell that fails this way keeps its slot.
- Daggerheart: you make a reaction roll with your Spellcast trait against the caster’s Difficulty. When it works, the card goes to your vault, and a card in your vault isn’t offered.
A countered spell still shows in the game log and on the result card, marked Countered, with who countered it and how. The caster’s action is used either way.
Changing a roll
Section titled “Changing a roll”When a creature in range is about to succeed on a roll your card answers, the prompt shows the roll against its target, for example Ogre’s WIS save (17 vs DC 15) is about to succeed. Press Confirm to use the card:
- Silvery Barbs makes them roll again and keep the lower result.
- Cutting Words takes your die off their total. It’s also offered when damage is about to land.
- The Daggerheart Archmage’s Counterspell makes a reaction roll against a player’s Spellcast Roll. If it succeeds, the Spellcast Roll fails. It can’t stop a critical success. When you confirm it as the GM, its Fear is spent for you, and each time it works it costs one more Fear. The count shows as a resource on the Archmage’s token, where you can clear it.
In a contest, you react to the side that is about to win.
Hope and Fear rerolls (Daggerheart)
Section titled “Hope and Fear rerolls (Daggerheart)”Cards that change a Duality roll are offered before it settles — to the roller, and to allies in range when the card says so. The prompt shows the roll, for example Your roll (Hope 4 / Fear 9, 15 vs Difficulty 14) is about to succeed, and what the card would do: reroll the Hope Die or the Fear Die, reroll both (some cards reroll with advantage), make it a roll with Hope, make a failure a success with Fear, swap the dice, or add to one. Press Confirm; if the card lets you choose the die, you’re asked which. These don’t use up your reaction.
Some cards turn the result and leave the dice as they are. True Strike makes your failed attack a success, Hope or Fear and all. Bone-Touched makes an attack that hit you fail, before any damage is rolled. When an environment is seated in the scene, the GM is offered its cards too — The House Always Wins on an adversary’s failing roll, wherever its token stands. See Environments at the table.
A condition can carry one of these for its bearer. When the GM plays the Hallowed Temple’s Relentless Hope, each PC gets a condition that offers them, once that scene, a Stress to turn their roll with Fear into a roll with Hope.
A card that makes your Hope Die bigger (“roll a d20 as your Hope Die”) is offered before you roll instead, with your Experiences: Add anything to the Action Roll? — pick it, or Roll without. See Adding an Experience to a card’s roll.
Some cards, like Silvery Barbs, then ask who has advantage? Pick a creature in range, yourself included. That creature has advantage on its next roll within the minute, applied automatically.
Rolls from your character sheet
Section titled “Rolls from your character sheet”An attack, a trait roll, a save or a weapon’s damage rolled from your character sheet at a table gets the same chance as a roll in a card play. Before the roll is reported, the cards that answer it are offered: your weapon’s Lucky (“On a failed attack, you can mark a Stress to reroll your attack”) or Rebounding, an ally’s reroll, an enemy’s Silvery Barbs. The game log shows the roll once, as it ends up.
A sheet roll with no Difficulty doesn’t know whether it succeeded. When that decides what’s offered (Lucky answers only a failure), you’re asked first: the prompt names the roll and asks did it succeed?. Answer It succeeded or It failed. When the answer makes no difference, you aren’t asked.
Answering incoming damage (Daggerheart)
Section titled “Answering incoming damage (Daggerheart)”When damage is about to land on your character and you hold a card that answers it — reduce it, halve it, mark Stress instead, take it for an ally — you’re asked first. The prompt, Incoming damage, shows the hit and what it costs (“Ogre’s physical damage: 14 — Major (mark 2 HP)”), lists your cards and, beside them, marking an Armor Slot. Choose any, or none to take it as it is, and press Submit Choice. An ally who can protect you sees Protect Kara? with their own cards. Unanswered after 30 seconds, the damage lands as it is.
What it costs, and who’s asked
Section titled “What it costs, and who’s asked”Using a reaction card spends your reaction and whatever the card costs: a spell slot, a Bardic Inspiration, or one of the card’s own uses.
- If you have no reaction left this round, or no slot to cast with, you aren’t asked.
- A card that works only under a condition isn’t offered until it holds. The Arch-Necromancer’s Not Today, My Dears (“when the Necromancer has marked 7 or more of their HP”) comes up only once 7 are marked.
- A card that answers a creature’s roll because of a condition on them is offered only for that creature’s rolls. Darkweave Venom’s Exhausted (“must mark a Stress each time they make an action roll”) asks the GM about the Exhausted PC’s rolls, and nobody else’s.
- If you decline a roll prompt, you aren’t asked again during the same play.
- When several creatures could react, the first to accept is the one who does, and the other prompts close.
- The GM answers for the creatures nobody controls — adversaries and environments — in the same kind of prompt players see, at the top right of the table. Answer before it closes: a roll or a hit waits about 30 seconds.
- A prompt goes away if whoever made the roll reloads the table partway through, or once it has waited past its time: nothing would come of an answer then.
Making a card that reacts
Section titled “Making a card that reacts”Set the card’s trigger to When a Spell Is Cast or When a Roll Is Made. The rules editor then asks how the counter decides, or what the card does to the roll and which rolls it answers. See Cards that answer the table.